The Transactional Nature of Human Relationships

Human relationships, when examined closely, reveal a fundamental truth that many find uncomfortable to acknowledge: they are inherently transactional. This doesn't diminish their value or beauty, but rather offers a clearer lens through which to understand why we connect with some people and drift away from others.

The Currency of Connection

At its core, every relationship operates on an exchange system. We gravitate toward people who provide something we value: emotional support, shared laughter, intellectual stimulation, or simply the comfort of familiarity. These connections persist because they fulfill our needs and make us feel good about ourselves. When someone shares our opinions, enjoys our favorite activities, or validates our worldview, they become valuable to us in ways that extend far beyond mere companionship.

This transactional nature isn't cynical or cold. It's human nature. We seek relationships that enhance our lives, and we maintain those that continue to provide mutual benefit.

The person who listens to our problems, the friend who shares our passion for hiking, the colleague who appreciates our sense of humor : each fulfills a specific role in our emotional ecosystem.

The Projection Problem

Much of our relationship disappointment stems from projection. We unconsciously expect others to think, feel, and behave as we do. When we meet someone who initially seems compatible, we often fill in the gaps with assumptions based on our own personality and preferences.

We imagine they'll react to situations the way we would, share our values, or prioritize the same things we find important.

This projection creates a false foundation for relationships. When reality inevitably reveals the differences between our expectations and their actual personality, disappointment follows. The friend who seemed so understanding suddenly appears selfish.

The romantic partner who shared our interests reveals conflicting life goals. The colleague we enjoyed working with shows a completely different approach to problem-solving.

The gap between projection and reality explains why so many promising relationships fizzle out after the initial honeymoon period. We weren't really connecting with the person themselves, but with our idealized version of who we thought they were.

A Better Approach to Building Connections

Rather than trying to fight against the transactional nature of relationships or the tendency to project, we can work with these realities to build more authentic connections. The key lies in focusing on our own genuine interests and activities.

When you pursue activities you truly enjoy, you naturally encounter people who share at least one authentic aspect of your personality. The person you meet at a pottery class, volunteer organization, or book club is there for similar reasons you are. This shared foundation provides a more honest starting point for connection than random encounters or relationships built primarily on proximity or convenience.

This approach offers several advantages :

1. First, you're already engaged in something that brings you joy, so you're likely to be at your most genuine and relaxed.
2. Second, the shared activity provides natural conversation topics and ongoing opportunities to interact.
3. Third, you can observe how potential friends or partners behave in real situations rather than in the artificial environment of a first date or initial meeting.

Embracing Realistic Expectations

Understanding the transactional nature of relationships doesn't mean becoming calculating or manipulative. Instead, it means approaching connections with realistic expectations and genuine self-awareness. Rather than expecting others to be extensions of ourselves, we can appreciate them for who they actually are and what they genuinely bring to our lives.

This perspective also helps us become better relationship partners ourselves. When we recognize that others are drawn to us for specific reasons, we can be more intentional about nurturing the qualities that make us valuable friends, partners, or colleagues. We can also be more honest about our own needs and boundaries rather than pretending we don't have any expectations at all.

The Beauty in the Exchange

Acknowledging that relationships are transactional doesn't diminish their profound impact on our lives. The love between partners, the loyalty between friends, and the support within families are all real and meaningful, even if they exist within a framework of mutual benefit. In fact, the most successful relationships are those where both parties clearly understand and appreciate what they give and receive from each other.

The goal isn't to eliminate the transactional aspect of human connection but to make those transactions as honest, fulfilling, and mutually beneficial as possible.

When we stop pretending that pure altruism drives all our relationships and instead embrace the beautiful complexity of human exchange, we create space for deeper, more sustainable connections.

By pursuing our authentic interests and meeting people along the way, we increase our chances of finding relationships where the transaction feels natural, fair, and enriching for everyone involved. In these connections, giving and receiving become so intertwined that the transactional nature fades into the background, replaced by the simple joy of genuine human connection.

Conclusion

At the end of the day, I think what I'm describing isn't really about cold calculations or keeping score in relationships. It's about recognizing that there's an unwritten contract governing how we connect with others, a fundamental dynamic that operates like a law of physics in the social world. It simply exists, whether we acknowledge it or not.

This underlying principle is more nuanced than simple give-and-take. It encompasses emotional needs, shared values, mutual growth, and the complex ways we fulfill each other's deeper requirements for connection and understanding. When we become aware of this natural law and work with it rather than against it, we create space for more authentic and fulfilling relationships.

The most meaningful connections in my life have been those where this unwritten contract feels balanced and natural, where both people intuitively understand what they're contributing and receiving, even if it's never explicitly discussed.

If you're interested in developing better relationship skills and emotional intelligence, I've created Herochall, an app that helps you level up your life in different areas of life. We got a topic that offers 30 challenges specifically designed to help you understand and improve your connections with others. These challenges focus on building emotional intelligence and relationship awareness, helping you put these insights into practice in your daily life.